Why You Need an Insurance Claims Lawyer on Your Side

An insurance claims lawyer is a legal professional who helps clients receive fair payments from insurance companies after accidents, injuries, or damages that should be covered under their insurance policies. Insurance claims lawyers, also known as insurance attorneys or plaintiff lawyers, provide legal advocacy and advice to make sure insurance companies properly fulfill their obligations.

The role of an insurance claims lawyer is to maximize payouts owed to their clients. They analyze insurance policies to determine what claims the insurer is required to pay. They gather evidence, conduct investigations, negotiate with insurance companies, and file lawsuits if needed, to make sure their clients are fully and fairly compensated under the terms of their insurance policies.  

By advocating for their clients’ best interests, insurance claims lawyers help protect individuals and businesses that suffered losses from being denied valid claims or receiving less compensation than they deserve. Their guidance can be essential for effectively navigating the complex insurance claims process and obtaining the maximum amount the insurer is obligated to pay.

Filing Insurance Claims

When you suffer a loss such as property damage, injuries, or lost wages, one of the first steps is filing an insurance claim. This starts the process of seeking compensation from your insurance company. However, insurance claims can be complex, with many requirements, deadlines, and opportunities for denials if not handled properly. This is where an insurance claims lawyer can help guide you through the initial claims process.

A lawyer experienced with insurance claims will advise you on important steps such as:

  • Documenting your losses – Your lawyer can help you gather police reports, medical records, repair estimates, and other documentation to prove your losses. This provides justification for the compensation you seek.
  • Completing claim forms accurately – Insurance claim forms require detailed information. With legal guidance, you can provide thorough and precise details, avoiding mistakes that could delay or jeopardize your claim.
  • Meeting notification and filing deadlines – There are strict notification and filing deadlines for insurance claims, often within days or weeks of a loss. Missing these can result in a denial. Your lawyer will ensure timely compliance.
  • Responding to insurer requests – After a claim is filed, the insurer may request additional information through letters, questionnaires or recorded statements. An attorney can help craft responses to avoid unintentionally damaging your claim. 
  • Negotiating an advance payment – Your lawyer may be able to negotiate an upfront advance payment from the insurer to cover urgent expenses while your claim is being processed.

With an experienced insurance claims lawyer, you can improve your chances of a satisfactory resolution from the outset. Legal expertise with the intricacies of claim filing helps establish a strong foundation for obtaining fair compensation in your case.

Negotiating Settlements With the Insurance Company

After filing an insurance claim, the next step is to negotiate a settlement with the insurance company. An experienced insurance claims lawyer knows how to effectively negotiate to maximize your settlement amount.

Here are some strategies lawyers use during negotiations:

  • Review the policy language in detail – Look for any ambiguities or provisions that support a higher settlement. Identify the policy limits and any areas where the insurer may have undervalued the claim.
  • Determine the full scope of damages – Gather evidence to prove all damages, including property damage, loss of income, pain and suffering, medical bills, etc. Quantify every loss in dollar amounts. 
  • Send a demand letter – Outline all damages and demand a settlement at the top of the policy limits. Provide documentation to justify the demand.
  • Negotiate up from any low offer – Don’t accept an initial low offer. Methodically negotiate up based on evidence for a higher amount.
  • Hold fast on important points – Don’t concede on key issues. Maintain your demand if it’s supported by evidence.
  • Be prepared to litigate – If needed, show willingness to take the claim to court if a fair settlement isn’t reached.

The goal is getting full compensation for all losses and maximizing the final claim amount. An experienced lawyer knows how to negotiate assertively, backed up by facts and documentation. With the right legal representation, you can often settle a claim for significantly more than what the insurer initially offered.


When an insurance claim is denied and cannot be settled through negotiations between the policyholder and insurance company, the next step is litigation. This involves filing a lawsuit against the insurance company to resolve the dispute in court. 

There are several reasons an insurance claim may end up in litigation:

  • The policyholder feels the insurance company wrongfully denied the claim or is not offering a fair settlement. They decide to sue to recoup the full amount they believe is owed under the policy.
  • The insurance company suspects fraud or misrepresentation by the policyholder and denies the claim on those grounds. The policyholder sues to prove the validity of their claim.
  • There is a major disagreement over the value of the claimed loss. For example, in a homeowner’s claim for fire damage, the insurer and homeowner are far apart on the reimbursement amount. 
  • The language, exclusions, or limitations in the policy are disputed, requiring a court to interpret the contract.
  • The insurance company engages in bad faith practices, like unjustly delaying payment of a valid claim. The policyholder sues for breach of contract and bad faith.

To build a strong case, insurance claims lawyers will gather all relevant evidence and documentation, consult with experts to assess damages and losses, take depositions from key witnesses, and research the law to construct persuasive legal arguments. 

Effective insurance lawyers are experienced trial attorneys who know how to present their case in the strongest light before a judge or jury. They will explain complex insurance policies in simple terms, offer a compelling narrative of events, refute any allegations of fraud, and advocate passionately for their client to receive the maximum just compensation under the law.

Specialty Areas

Lawyers that handle insurance claims often specialize in specific types of insurance and claims. Here is an overview of some common specialty areas:

Auto Insurance

Auto insurance claims involve accidents, collisions, theft, and damage to vehicles. An auto insurance lawyer can help negotiate a settlement or file a lawsuit against the at-fault driver’s insurance company. They have expertise in determining fault, fighting claim denials, maximizing payouts for vehicle repairs/replacement and medical treatments, as well as obtaining compensation for lost wages and pain and suffering.

Health Insurance  

Health insurance claims involve disputes with private health insurers or government programs like Medicare and Medicaid. A health insurance lawyer can assist with denied claims, limited coverage for treatments and procedures, excessive co-pays and deductibles, and continuity of care issues. They help maximize insurance benefits and appeal adverse determinations.

Homeowners Insurance

Homeowners insurance provides protection against damage and losses to homes and personal property. A homeowners insurance lawyer helps file claims for events like fires, water damage, storms, theft, and liability issues. They can assist with underpaid claims, non-renewals, and denial of coverage disputes.

Disability Insurance  

Disability insurance replaces lost income when injury or illness prevents working. A disability insurance attorney can help file long-term disability claims, negotiate satisfactory settlements, and appeal denied claims through litigation if necessary. They ensure all benefits are exhausted and help prove disability to maximize payouts.

Life Insurance

Life insurance lawyers assist beneficiaries with denied death benefit claims. They also represent policyholders regarding lapsed policies, improper policy cancellations, and misleading information by agents. A life insurance attorney can file lawsuits over bad faith dealings by insurers.

Hiring a Lawyer 

Deciding whether to hire a lawyer to assist with an insurance claim can be a difficult decision. An experienced insurance claims lawyer can be invaluable in maximizing your settlement, but legal fees can also cut into any payout you receive. Here are some tips on when it may make sense to hire a lawyer for an insurance claim:

Complex Claims

If your insurance claim involves complex legal issues or regulations, an attorney experienced in insurance law can help ensure you receive everything you’re entitled to under the policy. For example, claims involving bad faith insurance practices, denial of claims, or disputes over policy wording often benefit from legal expertise.

Large Claims 

For significant insurance claims involving serious property damage, long-term disability, or major injuries, hiring a lawyer is often advisable. The lawyer can review your policy, gather evidence, conduct investigations, negotiate aggressively on your behalf, and take the claim to litigation if needed. The legal fees may be well worth it to maximize your eventual payout.

Contingency Fees

Many insurance claims attorneys work on a contingency fee basis, meaning they only get paid if you receive a settlement. Typical contingency fees range from 25-40% of the total settlement amount. This reduces the financial risk of hiring a lawyer. Just be sure to understand fee agreements fully.

In general, for small clear-cut claims, hiring a lawyer may not make financial sense. But for complex claims or cases involving significant disputed amounts, consulting an attorney can be a wise investment to ensure you receive fair compensation for your losses.

Choosing a Lawyer

When you need to file an insurance claim, having the right lawyer can make all the difference. Here are some tips for selecting the ideal attorney to handle your insurance claim:

Specialization Matters 

Look for lawyers who specialize specifically in insurance law and regularly handle insurance claims. Avoid general practice attorneys – you want someone with deep expertise in this field.

Experience Counts

Choose a lawyer with extensive experience handling claims similar to yours. Ask prospects how many years they’ve practiced insurance law and how many claims like yours they’ve handled.

Communication Style

Make sure your attorney communicates clearly and listens attentively. You’ll be discussing complex issues, so mutual understanding is key.

Track Record of Success 

Ask prospects about their success rate with similar cases. A strong win record indicates they have the skills to successfully fight the insurance company.

Reputation with Insurers

Well-regarded lawyers develop working relationships with claims adjusters. Ask if the attorney has a reputation for reasonable negotiation with your insurance company.

Contingency Fees

Most insurance lawyers work on contingency, taking a percentage of your settlement. Make sure the fee percentage is reasonable.

Licenses in Your State

Verify the lawyer is licensed in your state and familiar with local insurance regulations. Laws vary between states.

Comfort Level

Most importantly, choose a lawyer you feel comfortable with and can trust through the claims process. Go with your gut feeling during consultations.

Ask key questions upfront to ensure the attorney has the specialization, track record, and approach to maximize your insurance claim payout. With the right legal guidance, you improve your chances of a satisfactory settlement.

Avoiding Denials

A common issue for insurance policyholders is improper claims denials. Insurance companies have complex claims review processes and will often deny claims for minor technicalities or clerical errors. Having an experienced insurance claims lawyer can help policyholders avoid these improper claim denials through several key strategies:

  • Thorough documentation – The lawyer will ensure all documentation related to the claim is organized, complete, and submitted properly. Missing information is one of the top reasons for claim denial, so having everything in order is critical.
  • Communication protocols – The lawyer will handle all communication with the insurance company, ensuring responses are prompt, compliant with regulations, and avoid any statements that could justify denial. Clear and proper communication from the beginning can prevent denial down the road.
  • Regulatory expertise – Insurance claims regulations are complex and frequently changing at both state and federal levels. An experienced lawyer will be up to date on all applicable regulations and make arguments preventing denial based on violation of those regulations.
  • Negotiation skills – Even when a claim denial seems imminent, a lawyer can often successfully negotiate with the insurance company. Having someone familiar with claims processes argue the validity of your claim and demand fair treatment can keep the claim from getting denied.
  • Litigation readiness – If negotiations fail, the lawyer will already have built a strong case so that litigation is a viable option. The threat of legal action can sometimes motivate an insurance company to reverse an improper denial and settle the claim.

Having a skilled insurance claims advocate in your corner from the very beginning of the claims process can help avoid the frustration of an improper denial. Their expertise and diligence can get your claim approved smoothly.

Maximizing Payouts

When you suffer a loss, having an experienced insurance claims lawyer on your side can help ensure you receive full and fair compensation for your damages. Here are some of the strategies lawyers use to get clients the maximum settlement or court award possible:

  • Thoroughly investigate the claim – A lawyer will gather all relevant documentation, conduct interviews, inspect property damage, consult experts, and leave no stone unturned to build the strongest case possible. This allows them to demonstrate the full extent of losses and expenses incurred.
  • Knowledge of legal rights – An attorney understands all the benefits and coverages clients are entitled to under the insurance policy and relevant laws. They ensure clients receive 100% of what they are owed.

Establish actual cash value

  • – For property damage claims, lawyers work with appraisers to carefully calculate the actual cash value of damaged or destroyed possessions, factoring in depreciation. This is often higher than the insurer’s initial offer.
  • Calculate all losses – Beyond property damage, an experienced lawyer identifies all additional losses stemming from the claim, including temporary housing, lost income, medical bills, pain and suffering, loss of enjoyment, and more. Thorough loss calculations result in a maximum payout.
  • Negotiation skills – During settlement talks, lawyers employ negotiation tactics to systematically increase offers until full value is achieved. Their knowledge of litigation costs often motivates insurers to settle.
  • Willingness to litigate – If fair compensation cannot be achieved through negotiation, an attorney has the experience to take the claim to court. Insurers know lawyers have the resources and expertise to win lawsuits, providing leverage during settlement.

With an extensive understanding of the claims process and laws governing insurance policies, a dedicated lawyer has the skills and tenacity to pursue maximum compensation for losses suffered. Their involvement can result in a substantially higher payout compared to what claimants may recover on their own.


Filing an insurance claim and negotiating a fair settlement can often be a complex and frustrating process for policyholders. An insurance claims lawyer can provide invaluable help through each stage. As summarized in this guide:

  • Insurance claims lawyers understand all the nuances of insurance policies and claims processes. They can identify potential issues early and help policyholders take the right steps to avoid problems or denials down the road.  
  • Lawyers are experienced negotiators. They know what settlements are reasonable and when a lowball offer should be rejected or countered. With an attorney’s advocacy, policyholders often receive significantly higher payouts.
  • If a claim does end up in litigation, a lawyer’s expertise in building a case and arguing before a judge or jury becomes critical. Without legal counsel, most policyholders would be at a major disadvantage.
  • Claims lawyers specialize in areas like personal injury, disability insurance, homeowner’s insurance, etc. Matching a lawyer’s expertise to the specifics of a claim helps ensure the best outcome.  
  • Lawyers work on a contingency fee basis for insurance claims. This means no payment is required upfront. Attorney fees only come out of any eventual settlement or court award.

The bottom line is that insurance claims lawyers level the playing field against big insurance companies. For policyholders who have suffered a loss, hiring experienced legal counsel is often essential to receiving fair compensation under their policy. Don’t leave money on the table – consult an attorney who can advocate for you.

Leave a Comment